Research Brief CB-01 · U.S. Labor Market Statistics

Why Household Surveys and Tax Filings Measure U.S. Side Income Differently

Economists studying supplementary work in the United States frequently encounter a persistent measurement puzzle: federal household surveys show relatively stable multiple-jobholding rates, whereas administrative tax records reveal a much larger volume of non-employee income filings.

The Household Survey Baseline

For decades, the primary benchmark for tracking secondary employment in the United States has been the Current Population Survey (CPS), conducted jointly by the U.S. Census Bureau and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). In the monthly CPS, respondents report whether they held more than one job during a specific reference week. Under this framework, multiple jobholders include workers combining two wage-and-salary positions as well as employees who also operate an unincorporated business or perform freelance assignments on the side.

According to historical BLS series, the share of employed American workers classified as multiple jobholders in the CPS has remained within a narrow band for years, fluctuating modestly around business cycles rather than rising sharply. A supplementary instrument, the BLS Contingent Worker Supplement (CWS), similarly asks respondents about their main job arrangement rather than every secondary source of earnings.

Administrative Tax Records and Divergent Trends

A contrasting picture emerged when labor economists compared survey responses directly against Internal Revenue Service administrative records. In an influential line of research, Katharine G. Abraham, John C. Haltiwanger, Kristin Sandusky, and James R. Spletzer linked individual CPS responses with federal tax filings, including Schedule C sole-proprietorship returns and Form 1099 information returns. Their analysis found that a substantial share of individuals who reported no self-employment activity in the household survey nonetheless had administrative tax records indicating self-employment receipts during the same calendar year.

Earlier work by Lawrence F. Katz and Alan B. Krueger also drew national attention to alternative work arrangements—covering independent contractors, on-call workers, and contract-firm employees—by fielding the 2015 RAND-Princeton Contingent Worker Survey and comparing results with the 2005 BLS Contingent Worker Supplement. Subsequent revisions by Katz and Krueger, together with the 2017 BLS release of an updated CWS, narrowed the estimated expansion of primary alternative work while confirming that informal and secondary freelance earnings remain difficult to capture in standard labor questionnaires.

Methodological Caveats in Both Data Sources

Neither data source provides a complete measurement of U.S. supplementary income, and researchers note significant methodological limitations on both sides. Household surveys such as the CPS rely on a single reference week, proxy reporting by one household member for another, and respondents' subjective interpretation of whether sporadic tasks qualify as a "job." As a result, occasional evening or weekend freelance work is frequently omitted from monthly survey counts.

Conversely, administrative tax records introduce their own distortions. Form 1099-NEC and Form 1099-K filings report gross receipts rather than net profit after expenses, and tax filings can capture asset rentals, resale of household goods, or passive partnership distributions that do not represent active labor hours. Additionally, reporting thresholds for third-party payment networks have shifted over time under federal legislation, meaning an increase in filed forms can reflect regulatory reporting changes rather than a genuine rise in underlying economic activity.

Implications for Interpreting Public Headlines

When commentary on the U.S. side-income economy cites dramatically different participation figures, the discrepancy usually stems from which statistical instrument is being referenced. Studies based on annual tax filings or broad online questionnaires count anyone who earned even minimal gross receipts across twelve months, while BLS monthly surveys focus on ongoing concurrent jobs within a single week. Reading both sources alongside their definitions clarifies why secondary work appears widespread in annual household budgets yet modest in weekly employment tables.

Editorial Notice: This brief summarizes publicly available U.S. labor research for educational reading. It makes no assumptions about any reader's work arrangements and does not represent tax or employment advice.